There's a moment many of us know well: you're sitting in a doctor's office, you've explained your symptoms for what feels like the hundredth time, and the response you get is a shrug, a generic diagnosis, or a prescription that addresses the side effects of another prescription. You leave feeling dismissed — and worse, doubting yourself.
That experience is exactly what drove Sarah Steward to become a holistic nutritionist and the founder of The Nutrition Steward. In a recent conversation on The Zero Proof Life podcast, Sarah sat down with host Carolyn Bennett to talk about her remarkable journey — from a childhood shaped by natural healing and international travel, to navigating a broken healthcare system as an adult, to building a practice dedicated to helping others do what she had to learn the hard way: trust their bodies.
A Childhood Rooted in Natural Healing
Sarah didn't grow up in a household that rushed to the doctor at the first sign of trouble. Raised by a mother she lovingly describes as a "hippie Mother Earth" type, she spent her early years learning home remedies and the art of self-care — often without health insurance at all. Her family's philosophy was simple: learn what your body needs, and don't rely too heavily on outside systems to tell you.
Before she was ten years old, Sarah had visited ten different countries with her parents, who worked overseas and brought her along for the ride. That early exposure to diverse cultures gave her something invaluable: the understanding that nothing in health — or in life — is purely black and white.
"Everybody has been exposed to different environments, different communities. That's why I look at everything as a whole. Nothing is ever black and white."
— Sarah Steward
She was homeschooled through eighth grade, spent much of her childhood alone or around adults, and later studied theology for nearly a decade at her father's urging. But throughout all of it, her body was trying to tell her something — and the conventional medical system wasn't helping her hear it.
When the System Fails You
In her twenties and early thirties, Sarah began experiencing symptoms that no doctor could explain. She was put on heavy prescription medications that caused anxiety — and was then told the anxiety was the problem. As a woman asking a healthcare system for answers about pain that couldn't be neatly categorized, she was met with skepticism, exhaustion of "limited resources," and ultimately a misdiagnosis of anxiety and fibromyalgia. She had neither.
Watching her father go through similar struggles with a system that failed him, and witnessing her husband navigate his own health journey, something clicked. If the answers weren't coming from outside, she would find them from within — starting with education.
"I was tired of feeling like it was someone else's job to make me better," she told Carolyn. "I was tired of feeling like it was someone else's job to tell me what was going on with my own body."
She dove into holistic nutrition and health — and the relief she found wasn't just physical. It was empowering.
Sobriety as a Missing Piece
Around 2010, Sarah made another significant shift: she got sober. Coming up on 16 years of sobriety, she's clear that it wasn't a dramatic rock-bottom story — but it was pivotal.
In her early twenties, alcohol was simply "just there" — a social default, a rite of passage, never questioned. But as she began observing herself and the people around her, she started noticing something: the conversations felt vacant. The connection felt hollow. And when she was trying to manage undiagnosed pain with prescription medications, substances of any kind were only prolonging what needed to be faced.
"All that's doing is prolonging the pain. Because the problem is still there. What you're going through is still there."
— Sarah Steward
Her sobriety wasn't just about stopping something — it was about clearing space for her real healing to begin. And in that, she found the final piece of her own puzzle.
Empaths, Emotions, and the Body
One of the most powerful threads of the conversation emerged when Sarah and Carolyn began talking about empathy — and how deeply felt emotions, left unprocessed, can manifest in the body.
Sarah has noticed a pattern in her work: many women who struggle with substances — including alcohol — are deep feelers. Empaths. People who experience the world with a level of sensitivity that the world has often labeled as "too much." And without healthy outlets, that intensity can become something to manage, to dull, to escape.
"Our sensitivity is really our superpower," Sarah said. "But it is so common to try to find something to calm that — to dampen it, almost — without even realizing that's what we're doing."
She pointed to the thyroid as one physical example. Imbalances there, she's observed, are often connected to a feeling of being unable to use one's voice — swallowing feelings, suppressing needs, holding back in relationships or with doctors. The body, she says, will find a way to express what the mind won't let through.
"If you can't speak out, it will manifest elsewhere."
The prescription? Not perfection. Not a complete dietary overhaul. Start with stress. Start with sleep. Start with learning to let your emotions move through you rather than building walls to keep them out.
A Message for Anyone Feeling Lost
As the conversation wound down, Carolyn asked Sarah what she would want to say to someone who feels overwhelmed — by their health, by the healthcare system, or by the quiet suspicion that alcohol (or something else) might be getting in the way of their healing.
Her answer was gentle, direct, and full of grace:
"Please don't avoid these feelings. Lean into them. Intuition presents itself first — before doubt moves in. And there can be a day one at any time. At any age. You can start over anywhere."
— Sarah Steward
She also reminded listeners that health isn't compartmentalized. The run, the salad, the therapy session, the choice not to open a bottle of wine — they aren't separate acts. They're one body, one life, working in concert.
Sarah's Self-Inquiry Questions for Sober Curiosity
These questions are offered for personal reflection — no one needs to know your answers but you.
- What role does this substance currently play in my daily or weekly life?
- In what situations is the urge the strongest?
- What emotions, stressors, or patterns tend to come just before I use?
- What am I hoping to feel more of — relaxed, connected, energized, numb, distracted?
- What am I hoping to feel less of?
- How does my body feel the next day? How does it affect my sleep, digestion, mood, or energy?
- If this substance were no longer available, what would feel most challenging?
- Does this pattern align with my long-term health goals?
- If I'm not dependent — what would taking a short break reveal?
- Is my body benefiting from this pattern, or simply adapting to it?
You don't need a label. You don't need a dramatic story. You just need to be willing to start — even if "starting" looks like sitting quietly with one of those questions and seeing what comes up.
Your body has been talking all along.
Sarah Steward — The Nutrition Steward
Sarah is a holistic nutritionist and holistic health practitioner helping individuals understand their body's unique needs through education, accountability, and compassion. Her work is shaped by her own experience with misdiagnosis and nearly 16 years of sobriety.
nutritionsteward.com →@thenutritionsteward on Instagram →